An original Addaly classroom starter · 40 minutes
A confident answer. A better question.
A 40-minute, teacher-led introduction to evidence, generalisation and checking an answer. Use a shared screen or teach the entire lesson with paper.
The learning goal
By the end, learners can identify a claim, test it against the available evidence, find a counterexample and explain a careful correction.
Before the lesson
- Read the plan and the answer key first. Adapt the vocabulary, group size and pace to the learners’ age, language and context.
- Prepare the four shapes below. Keep D out of view until the source-check activity. Pair learners so one explains and the other asks for evidence.
- No student login, AI chat, paid tool or live web search is needed. Do not enter names or personal information into a tool for this activity.
- If you later choose to create child accounts, first review the school’s policy, age requirements, permissions and consent process. This starter does not require accounts.
What you need · Shared screen
One teacher-controlled screen; this guide; a board or a sheet of paper for each pair. Open any optional reading before class if you plan to use it.
Your 40-minute plan
The source for the exercise
Invented claimAll shapes are blue.
- Ablue · circle
- Bblue · square
- Cblue · hexagon
- Damber · triangle
A, B and C are visible. D is deliberately hidden for the opening activity.
Notice before you judge
Separate an observation from a claim.
You might sayHere are three examples. What can you say just from what you can see? What would be a bigger claim than the evidence allows?
- Show A, B and C only. Give learners one quiet minute to note what they observe.
- Ask pairs to compare: ‘The three shapes shown are blue’ and ‘All shapes are blue’. Write both sentences exactly.
- Take two explanations. Ask which sentence talks only about the examples and which talks about every shape.
In your setup · Shared screenKeep the fourth shape hidden. Point to A, B and C as learners give their observations.
Ask the classWhich words make the second sentence a stronger claim?
Understand the leap
Explain why a few examples do not prove a universal claim.
You might sayImagine an answer card says: ‘All shapes are blue.’ This is an invented claim for our exercise, not an answer produced by an AI system. A confident sentence can go beyond the examples behind it.
- Ask pairs to underline the claim and circle ‘all’. Ask what evidence would be needed to defend that word.
- Let learners propose a test that could show the claim is wrong. Do not reveal D yet.
- Connect carefully to AI: a model may generalise from examples and can produce an unsupported answer. This small logic exercise is an analogy, not a demonstration of how every model works.
- Check the distinction: three observed blue shapes support a statement about those examples; they do not establish the colour of every shape.
In your setup · Shared screenUse the claim card below. A live chatbot or generated answer is unnecessary.
Ask the classWhat single example would be enough to challenge the word ‘all’?
Check the full source
Use a counterexample and revise the answer.
You might sayNow we can inspect the complete source for this exercise: four labelled shapes. Check the claim against every item. Record what the source shows, not what you expected.
- Reveal D, the amber triangle. Give pairs three minutes to inspect A–D and record the relevant evidence.
- Use the worksheet: copy the claim, name the counterexample, choose a verdict and write a narrower replacement.
- Swap worksheets. The second pair must point to the exact shape that supports the verdict and check whether the replacement overclaims.
- Discuss two possible corrections: ‘Not all shapes are blue’ and ‘Three of the four shapes in this source are blue’. Both fit this source; neither tells us the colour of every other shape.
- If time remains, ask whether ‘All triangles are amber’ is justified by one amber triangle. It is not established by this source.
In your setup · Shared screenSelect ‘Reveal the full source’. Keep the four shapes on screen during the pair check.
Ask the classWhat does D disprove, and what does it leave unanswered?
Explain, then leave a trace
Make the reasoning visible in a short explanation and exit ticket.
You might sayExplain the change in your own words: ‘At first the claim said… The source shows… Therefore I would change it to… I still cannot conclude…’
- Give each partner one minute to explain. The listener asks ‘Which item is your evidence?’ and ‘What is still unknown?’
- Invite two pairs to share. Correct the reasoning together without ranking learners or rewarding confidence over evidence.
- Use the three exit prompts below. A sentence or a quick drawing is enough; collect on paper if you want a classroom record.
- Close with a transferable habit: identify the claim, inspect the source, look for a counterexample and state the limit of your conclusion.
In your setup · Shared screenDisplay the exit prompts. Learners answer on paper; no submission or account is needed.
Ask the classHow would you check a convincing answer when you cannot inspect its source?
Pair worksheet
Copy onto blank paper or print this guide. There is no online submission.
- The exact claim: __________________________________________________
- The source items I checked (A, B, C, D): _____________________________
- The item that challenges the claim, and what it shows: ______________
- My verdict: supported by this source / contradicted / not established
- My careful replacement sentence: ___________________________________
- One thing this source does not tell us: ____________________________
- My partner’s evidence question, and my reply: ______________________
Exit ticket
- Name the counterexample and explain why it matters.
- Write one sentence that the four shapes actually support.
- Name one thing you would do before trusting a convincing AI answer.
For teacher preparation
Teacher answer key
- The invented claim ‘All shapes are blue’ is contradicted by D, an amber triangle. Shape labels and colour words make the exercise usable without colour vision or a colour printer.
- A, B and C are blue; D is amber. ‘Three of the four shapes shown are blue’ is supported. ‘Not all shapes are blue’ also follows. One counterexample defeats this universal claim.
- The source does not establish the colours of shapes outside this set, or that all triangles are amber. Do not replace one unsupported universal claim with another.
- A strong explanation identifies D, links it to the verdict and states a limit. For the AI exit prompt, accept a sensible step such as opening the original source, checking a citation or seeking independent evidence; do not require a particular product.
Optional next reading
The following lessons are in English. The complete starter guide above is available in English and Hindi.