An original Addaly classroom starter · 40 minutes

A confident answer. A better question.

A 40-minute, teacher-led introduction to evidence, generalisation and checking an answer. Use a shared screen or teach the entire lesson with paper.

Guide language
Teaching setup

The learning goal

By the end, learners can identify a claim, test it against the available evidence, find a counterexample and explain a careful correction.

Before the lesson

  1. Read the plan and the answer key first. Adapt the vocabulary, group size and pace to the learners’ age, language and context.
  2. Prepare the four shapes below. Keep D out of view until the source-check activity. Pair learners so one explains and the other asks for evidence.
  3. No student login, AI chat, paid tool or live web search is needed. Do not enter names or personal information into a tool for this activity.
  4. If you later choose to create child accounts, first review the school’s policy, age requirements, permissions and consent process. This starter does not require accounts.

What you need · Shared screen

One teacher-controlled screen; this guide; a board or a sheet of paper for each pair. Open any optional reading before class if you plan to use it.

Your 40-minute plan

  1. 0–5 minNotice before you judge
  2. 5–15 minUnderstand the leap
  3. 15–30 minCheck the full source
  4. 30–40 minExplain, then leave a trace

The source for the exercise

Invented claimAll shapes are blue.

  • Ablue · circle
  • Bblue · square
  • Cblue · hexagon

A, B and C are visible. D is deliberately hidden for the opening activity.

A deliberately invented, closed source for a logic exercise. It contains four shapes, not facts about the outside world. This is not a generated AI answer or a model-performance test.
0–5 min · 5 min

Notice before you judge

Separate an observation from a claim.

You might say

Here are three examples. What can you say just from what you can see? What would be a bigger claim than the evidence allows?

  1. Show A, B and C only. Give learners one quiet minute to note what they observe.
  2. Ask pairs to compare: ‘The three shapes shown are blue’ and ‘All shapes are blue’. Write both sentences exactly.
  3. Take two explanations. Ask which sentence talks only about the examples and which talks about every shape.

In your setup · Shared screenKeep the fourth shape hidden. Point to A, B and C as learners give their observations.

Ask the classWhich words make the second sentence a stronger claim?

5–15 min · 10 min

Understand the leap

Explain why a few examples do not prove a universal claim.

You might say

Imagine an answer card says: ‘All shapes are blue.’ This is an invented claim for our exercise, not an answer produced by an AI system. A confident sentence can go beyond the examples behind it.

  1. Ask pairs to underline the claim and circle ‘all’. Ask what evidence would be needed to defend that word.
  2. Let learners propose a test that could show the claim is wrong. Do not reveal D yet.
  3. Connect carefully to AI: a model may generalise from examples and can produce an unsupported answer. This small logic exercise is an analogy, not a demonstration of how every model works.
  4. Check the distinction: three observed blue shapes support a statement about those examples; they do not establish the colour of every shape.

In your setup · Shared screenUse the claim card below. A live chatbot or generated answer is unnecessary.

Ask the classWhat single example would be enough to challenge the word ‘all’?

15–30 min · 15 min

Check the full source

Use a counterexample and revise the answer.

You might say

Now we can inspect the complete source for this exercise: four labelled shapes. Check the claim against every item. Record what the source shows, not what you expected.

  1. Reveal D, the amber triangle. Give pairs three minutes to inspect A–D and record the relevant evidence.
  2. Use the worksheet: copy the claim, name the counterexample, choose a verdict and write a narrower replacement.
  3. Swap worksheets. The second pair must point to the exact shape that supports the verdict and check whether the replacement overclaims.
  4. Discuss two possible corrections: ‘Not all shapes are blue’ and ‘Three of the four shapes in this source are blue’. Both fit this source; neither tells us the colour of every other shape.
  5. If time remains, ask whether ‘All triangles are amber’ is justified by one amber triangle. It is not established by this source.

In your setup · Shared screenSelect ‘Reveal the full source’. Keep the four shapes on screen during the pair check.

Ask the classWhat does D disprove, and what does it leave unanswered?

30–40 min · 10 min

Explain, then leave a trace

Make the reasoning visible in a short explanation and exit ticket.

You might say

Explain the change in your own words: ‘At first the claim said… The source shows… Therefore I would change it to… I still cannot conclude…’

  1. Give each partner one minute to explain. The listener asks ‘Which item is your evidence?’ and ‘What is still unknown?’
  2. Invite two pairs to share. Correct the reasoning together without ranking learners or rewarding confidence over evidence.
  3. Use the three exit prompts below. A sentence or a quick drawing is enough; collect on paper if you want a classroom record.
  4. Close with a transferable habit: identify the claim, inspect the source, look for a counterexample and state the limit of your conclusion.

In your setup · Shared screenDisplay the exit prompts. Learners answer on paper; no submission or account is needed.

Ask the classHow would you check a convincing answer when you cannot inspect its source?

Pair worksheet

Copy onto blank paper or print this guide. There is no online submission.

  1. The exact claim: __________________________________________________
  2. The source items I checked (A, B, C, D): _____________________________
  3. The item that challenges the claim, and what it shows: ______________
  4. My verdict: supported by this source / contradicted / not established
  5. My careful replacement sentence: ___________________________________
  6. One thing this source does not tell us: ____________________________
  7. My partner’s evidence question, and my reply: ______________________

Exit ticket

  1. Name the counterexample and explain why it matters.
  2. Write one sentence that the four shapes actually support.
  3. Name one thing you would do before trusting a convincing AI answer.

For teacher preparation

Teacher answer key

  1. The invented claim ‘All shapes are blue’ is contradicted by D, an amber triangle. Shape labels and colour words make the exercise usable without colour vision or a colour printer.
  2. A, B and C are blue; D is amber. ‘Three of the four shapes shown are blue’ is supported. ‘Not all shapes are blue’ also follows. One counterexample defeats this universal claim.
  3. The source does not establish the colours of shapes outside this set, or that all triangles are amber. Do not replace one unsupported universal claim with another.
  4. A strong explanation identifies D, links it to the verdict and states a limit. For the AI exit prompt, accept a sensible step such as opening the original source, checking a citation or seeking independent evidence; do not require a particular product.

Optional next reading

The following lessons are in English. The complete starter guide above is available in English and Hindi.