Design, before Any Software · Chapter 05

Why a near-touch is worse than an overlap

1:49 · Narrated with a synthetic voice. Captions are available in the player.

Read the transcript

Composition. One mechanism here is worth more than every rule of thirds diagram you have seen. Occlusion, one thing covering part of another, is the strongest depth cue the visual system has, and it is completely unambiguous: if one shape hides part of another, it is in front. Now take that away. When two contours come within a hair of each other without clearly overlapping, there is no evidence about which is nearer, and continuity fuses them into a single shape. That is the lamp post growing out of somebody’s head. Overlap clearly, or separate clearly. Three pixels apart is the one bad option, and it is the one people settle for. And a crop is a decision about what leaves, not about what stays. The same photograph of a vegetable market, cropped three ways, is about a market, about a transaction, or about a person. Asking what is being removed makes you look at the context, which is where the decision actually lives. One practical rule if a single image has to serve several places. Design in the tallest ratio you need, and keep everything load-bearing inside the intersection of all the crops you will be asked for. A square crop of a vertical frame throws away the top and the bottom. Platforms change their crops without telling anybody, and margin is the only durable defence.

Sources and further reading (1)