AI, Safety and What Goes WrongLesson 23 of 73

Module 3 · Truth, sources and verification

How professional checkers actually work

In this lesson

  • 7 min read
  • 5 reading sections
  • Knowledge check
  • Lesson 6 of 8 in this chapter

This chapter’s goalEstimate from the shape of a question how likely a fabrication is, verify a claim at a cost proportional to the consequence of being wrong, and explain why a cited source that exists is not yet a verified claim.

This chapter’s media

The film explains chapter ideas. The audiobook narrates the complete teaching text.

FormatEnglishहिंदी
Chapter filmNot availableWatch2:37
Full audiobookNot availableNot available
Reading down the page against reading sidewaysVertical reading: the historians and undergraduatesRead the site carefully, top to bottomExamined the design and the About pageWeighed the arguments on their meritsFrequently fooledLateral reading: the professional fact-checkersLeft the page within secondsOpened new tabs on the organisation and theclaimRead what independent sources said about itFast, and accurateThe historians and students were fooled; the fact-checkers were fast and right. A fluent paragraph anda well-built page both look exactly like good ones, which is why judging them by reading harder doesnot work.
The historians and students were fooled; the fact-checkers were fast and right. A fluent paragraph and a well-built page both look exactly like good ones, which is why judging them by reading harder does not work.

Figure

A little at a time

Explore an idea, try it, then check what stays.

Step 1 of 7Free · no account needed
Lesson steps

The counter-intuitive finding

In a study at Stanford, historians, undergraduates and professional fact-checkers were given unfamiliar websites and asked to judge their reliability. The historians and students did what educated people do: they read the site carefully, examined its design, looked at its About page, weighed its arguments. They were frequently fooled.

The fact-checkers were fast and accurate, and the reason was that they barely read the site at all. Within seconds they had left it, opened new tabs, and were reading what other sources said about the organisation. The researchers called this lateral reading, as opposed to reading vertically down the page.

Scrutinising a fluent paragraph for signs of falsehood is the historians’ strategy, and it fails for the same reason: a well-constructed page and a well-constructed paragraph both look exactly like a good one. Leave, and check elsewhere.

Your place and first choices stay on this browser. Classroom credit is recorded separately.

Stuck on something?Ask Rukmini, your AI tutor

How to cite: Addaly (2026) ‘How professional checkers actually work’, in AI, Safety and What Goes Wrong. Edited by M. Mun. Addaly. Available at: https://addaly.com/learn/ai-and-you/the-second-source-habit (Accessed: 21 November 2026).