AI, Safety and What Goes WrongLesson 60 of 73

Module 8 · Ownership, law and the public record

The training data question, unresolved

In this lesson

  • 10 min read
  • 6 reading sections
  • Knowledge check
  • Lesson 3 of 8 in this chapter

This chapter’s goalState who owns a given AI output in a named jurisdiction, describe the shape of the training-data dispute without pretending it is settled, and comply with the disclosure duties that already bind you.

This chapter’s media

The film explains chapter ideas. The audiobook narrates the complete teaching text.

FormatEnglishहिंदी
Chapter filmNot availableWatch3:10
Full audiobookNot availableNot available
The training-data question, as the courts have left it2019EU Digital Single Market Directive: text and data mining permitted, with amachine-readable opt-out for rights-holders2024ANI files against OpenAI in the Delhi High Court2025Thomson Reuters v Ross: fair use rejected where headnotes built a competing legalresearch tool2025Bartz v Anthropic: training on books held transformative; retaining a piratedlibrary held not to be2025Kadrey v Meta: judgment for the developer on the record, expressly not a generalrule2025Getty v Stability (UK): judgment turns largely on trade mark; the training questionstays unsettledThe pattern so far: acquisition is separated from use, market substitution weighs heavily, and nocourt has announced a general rule. India’s enumerated fair dealing leaves less room for anAmerican-style transformative-use argument.
The pattern so far: acquisition is separated from use, market substitution weighs heavily, and no court has announced a general rule. India's enumerated fair dealing leaves less room for an American-style transformative-use argument.

Figure

A little at a time

Explore an idea, try it, then check what stays.

Step 1 of 8Free · no account needed
Lesson steps

Do not expect an answer here

Whether training a model on copyrighted work without permission is lawful is being decided right now, in several countries, under different laws, with rulings pointing in different directions.

The claim on each side

Rights-holders argue that building a commercial product required copying their work; that the copying was at industrial scale; that some material was obtained from pirate sources; that models can reproduce protected expression; and that the output competes in the market for the originals, sometimes directly.

Developers argue that training extracts uncopyrightable statistical patterns rather than expression; that the use is transformative because the model does something different from the original work; that no copy is distributed to users; and that requiring permission for every work would make the technology impossible, which is an argument about consequences rather than doctrine.

Both positions contain something true, which is why this is hard.

Your place and first choices stay on this browser. Classroom credit is recorded separately.

Stuck on something?Ask Rukmini, your AI tutor

How to cite: Addaly (2026) ‘The training data question, unresolved’, in AI, Safety and What Goes Wrong. Edited by M. Mun. Addaly. Available at: https://addaly.com/learn/ai-and-you/the-training-data-dispute (Accessed: 21 November 2026).